in , , , ,

Debunking Myths: The Role of Seed Oils in Health

In the early part of the previous decade, the notion of detrimental seed oils began to firmly plant itself in the minds of the general public. Prominent voices on social media platforms initiated a campaign railing against what came to be dubbed ‘the pernicious octad’: soy, corn, rice bran, canola, sunflower, safflower, grapeseed, and cottonseed oil. These voices kicked up grand claims, asserting that these seed-based oils were the root cause of severe health afflictions, encompassing everything from cardiovascular disease to cancer, and even chronic inflammation.

The realm of food and nutritional science is often a labyrinth of perplexing statements and contradicting data. However, certain areas within this scientific field possess extensive research and substantial supporting evidence. One such area is the health benefits associated with polyunsaturated fats, including the omega-6 fatty acids that are a central characteristic of vegetable seed oils.

The vast majority of seed oils contain a compound known as linoleic acid, an omega-6 fat. The National Academy of Sciences, a highly esteemed scientific organization, suggests that adults should ingest approximately 12 to 17 grams of linoleic acid each day. In an updated advisory from the American Heart Association in 2009, it was underscored that 5 to 10% of daily caloric intake should hail from these polyunsaturated fats.

A consequential statement in 2017 from the American Heart Association’s presidency concluded that reducing saturated fat intake and substituting it with omega-6 fats could lead to a significant decrease in rates of heart disease. A popular counter-argument put forth posits that omega-6 fats, which are prevalent in seed oils, stir up inflammation within the human body.

However, this assertion was directly challenged and debunked through a comprehensive review of 15 randomized controlled trials in 2012. There is also a school of thought suggesting our bodies require a higher intake of omega-3 fats compared to omega-6 fats. Unfortunately, options to bolster consumption of omega-3s are rather limited.

Flax oil, also identifiable as linseed oil, stands as the only plant-derived fat that holds a higher omega-3 to omega-6 ratio. Other viable sources for omega-3 fats include walnuts, soy oil, and canola oil. Interestingly, these three sources also outweigh in favor of omega-6 fats, rather than omega-3. It becomes unlikely and unpractical for most individuals to inundate their culinary regime with large volumes of flax oil.

Given the circumstances, what recourse are we left with? Striking a balance appears to be the golden principle, along with striving for a healthier diet that zeroes in on the more harmful culprits. For instance, many ultra-processed food items contain seed oils. These food products, such as soda drinks, fast food, and other low-nutrition items, are heavily laden with added sugars, sodium, and saturated fats.

The real benefit would derive from a considerable cutback in American’s consumption of ultra-processed foods. Therefore, it is advisable not to stress overly on eliminating seed oils from your everyday dietary plan, particularly if they are utilized in small quantities for concocting salad dressings, sautéing, and baking.

In your culinary endeavors, viable alternatives such as olive oil and avocado oil can also be excellent options, provided they do not strain your budget. Even butter can prove to be an acceptable choice, albeit in modest quantities. While dining out, it would be wise to keep a check on, or possibly refrain from, ultra-processed foods, inclusive of those that introduce seed oils, and deep-fried food items.

Given the comprehensive and thoroughly researched data in this area, it is advocated to opt for replacements for saturated fats like butter, beef tallow, and lard with polyunsaturated options, such as the aforementioned seed oils. But remember, it is unnecessary to dispose of all your seed oil supplies to replace them with animal fats.