in

Kamala Harris: Identity Politics Over Meaningful Change

The journey towards political clout for African Americans has been challenging in the history of the United States. The legacy of egregious systems like slavery and racial discrimination – such as the notorious Black Codes and Jim Crow laws – have oppressed and limited African Americans’ civil and political liberties for extensive periods. Yet, due to persistent activism and significant sacrifices, African Americans eventually earned some level of political recognition. Perhaps nowhere is this more evident than in the capital city of the U.S., Washington, D.C.

A series of pioneering African Americans have served in various political roles, thereby contributing to reshaping the face of American politics. Often, their rise to power is portrayed as a breakthrough or symbol of progress. However, whether these individuals truly embody the values and interests of the broader Black community can be a matter of contentious debate.

Hiram Rhodes Revels joined the political map as a remarkable figure in 1870 when he ascended to the United States Senate, making history as the first African-American member of Congress. Originally from North Carolina, Revels served as a minister within the African Methodist Episcopal Church. His role during the Civil War was a chaplain for the U.S. Army. Following the war, he relocated to Mississippi, where he served in the state Senate.

While the Mississippi State Legislature selected Revels to represent the state during the Reconstruction era, his Senate term was quite short, only filling a vacancy from the Civil War era for a little over a year. Known for his advocacy against segregation regulations, Revels emphasized the civil rights of African Americans. Somehow, even with these credentials, Revels quickly disappeared from the political scene after his brief time in the Senate.

Joseph Hayne Rainey was another historic figure of this era, becoming the first African American to join the U.S. House of Representatives. He represented South Carolina and later served in the state Senate. Afterward, he was elected to fill a vacant House seat and was subsequently re-elected for four full terms. His achievements include being the first African-American to preside over the House of Representatives from the Speaker’s chair, as a member of the House Select Committee on the Freedmen’s Bank.

Shirley Chisholm, a noted politician, aimed for the highest office in the land, attempting to become the first African American and first woman to secure nomination through a major party for the presidency. Prior to this ambitious endeavor, she had already made waves as the first Black woman elected to Congress. Yet, despite her status, Chisholm couldn’t secure significant mainstream support during her presidential run.

John Lewis, a known civil rights activist, became representative of Georgia’s 5th Congressional District in the U.S. House. Lewis maintained his activism, including protest against apartheid in South Africa, during his 33-year service tenure. However, his stance brought into question whether by focusing on international issues, he was prioritizing global politics over the specific needs of his constituents.

Andrew Young, a leader in the civil rights movement, is known to have taken strides in the diplomacy community of the United States, after running for public office. Jesse Jackson Sr., while not the first African American to aspire to the presidency, rose as a contender with a potential chance at securing the Democratic Party’s nomination. However, despite his high hopes, his campaigns failed to achieve their ultimate goal.

John Conyers Jr.’s long tenure in the U.S. House of Representatives spanning over half a century was not without controversy. Yet, the representative from Michigan broke new ground for African-Americans in Congress and beyond. Carol Moseley Braun, from Illinois, received the title of being the first African American woman elected to the U.S. Senate, and she was notably the first African American senator from the Democratic Party.

Colin Powell emerged as a leading figure in national security circles as the first African-American U.S. secretary of state. Yet his tenure was overshadowed by the controversial decision to invade Iraq on the premise of weapon of mass destruction that were, unfortunately, never found.

On the 6th of January, 2023, U.S. Rep. Hakeem Jeffries, a Democrat from New York, reached a milestone, elected by House Democrats to serve as a minority leader. Even this achievement was not without cynicism. The national political scene remains divisive, and the effectiveness of such positions in forging real change is arguably limited.

Barack Obama unquestionably entered the political arena as a well-known figure, due to his tenure as the first African American president. His popularity is widely acknowledged yet, his impact and legacy remain a contentious topic.

Vice President Kamala Harris may have broken several glass ceilings in her career, considering gender and racial aspects, critics argue that she too often prioritizes identity politics over concrete policies to improve the lives of everyday Americans. Her representation of Black power, following in Obama’s footsteps, does not universally translate into substantive improvements for the Black community.