During a recent episode of The View, co-host Whoopi Goldberg voiced her disapproval of former U.S. Marine Daniel Penny’s public celebration following his acquittal in the death of Jordan Neely. Goldberg did not hold back, stating, “You killed a guy,” while questioning the appropriateness of Penny’s actions after the court verdict.
Penny had been charged with negligent homicide following the May 2023 incident on a New York City subway, where he placed Jordan Neely, a homeless man displaying erratic and aggressive behavior, in a chokehold that ultimately led to Neely’s death. After deliberating for weeks, the jury found Penny not guilty, citing his claim of self-defense and the intention to protect other passengers.
Goldberg’s Concerns
Goldberg took issue not only with the acquittal but also with Penny’s decision to publicly celebrate the outcome, including an appearance at a Manhattan bar with his legal team. “It just feels off to see someone going out and celebrating when a man is dead,” Goldberg said. She stressed that regardless of the legal outcome, a life was lost, and that should not be a cause for celebration.
Her comments have resonated with some viewers who share her discomfort over Penny’s post-verdict actions, arguing that a more subdued response would have been more appropriate, given the circumstances.
The Broader Debate
The case has reignited a national conversation about public safety, mental health, and the appropriate use of force in tense situations. Jordan Neely, a former street performer with a history of mental health issues, was reportedly acting erratically and threatening passengers on the subway. Penny intervened, claiming he acted to protect himself and others, but critics argue that his actions were excessive and unnecessarily lethal.
Penny’s acquittal has deeply divided public opinion. Supporters argue that the jury’s decision was just and that Penny acted out of necessity. Critics, including Goldberg, contend that the incident reflects broader systemic failures, such as inadequate mental health resources and a lack of support for the homeless population.
Reactions to Goldberg’s Comments
Goldberg’s remarks have drawn mixed reactions. Some praised her for highlighting the human cost of the incident, emphasizing the need for accountability and empathy in such cases. Others criticized her for what they perceived as an unfair characterization of Penny, who has maintained that he acted in self-defense and expressed regret over Neely’s death.
Moving Forward
The debate surrounding the Penny case highlights the complex intersection of self-defense, public safety, and the treatment of vulnerable populations. While the legal case is closed, the societal issues it underscores remain unresolved. Goldberg’s comments have added to the discourse, challenging the public to reflect on how such incidents should be addressed and what responses are appropriate in their aftermath.
As the conversation continues, the case of Daniel Penny and Jordan Neely will likely remain a touchpoint for discussions about justice, mental health, and the responsibilities of individuals in public spaces.